Centerville Pie Co. Expands Signature Line with New Ice Cream Pies and Small Savory Pies

Comfort food has always been about more than what is on the plate.

It is about tradition, family gatherings, celebrations, and the familiar flavors people return to time and time again. Whether shared around a holiday table, enjoyed after a long day, or served at a special occasion, great comfort food has a unique ability to bring people together.

Centerville Pie Co. has built its reputation around that idea, creating handcrafted pies that have become staples for customers across Cape Cod and beyond. Founded in 2009 by long-time friends Laurie Bowen and Kristin Broadley, the company began as a humble pie shop on Cape Cod with a passion for delivering homemade quality and comforting flavors.

The business quickly became an overnight sensation when Oprah Winfrey tried Centerville Pie Co.'s signature chicken pie and named it one of her "Favorite Things." That national recognition helped introduce the brand to pie lovers across the country and established Centerville Pie Co. as a standout name in comfort food.

Today, the company remains dedicated to delivering delicious, high-quality savory and sweet pies to customers on Cape Cod and throughout the United States.

Now, the beloved bakery and comfort food destination is introducing a new chapter in its story with the expansion of its signature product lineup.

The company has announced two major additions to its offerings: a refreshed collection of Ice Cream Pies and a new lineup of small savory pies, including the Small Chicken Pot Pie, Small Shepherd’s Pie, and Small Chicken Pie without vegetables. The new savory options are designed for grocery shoppers seeking convenient, high-quality meal solutions.

A Brand Built On Comfort And Tradition

Centerville Pie Co. has long understood that great food creates lasting memories.

Over the years, its sweet and savory pies have become part of family traditions, holiday celebrations, neighborhood gatherings, and everyday meals. While many food brands chase trends, Centerville Pie Co. has remained focused on delivering products that feel familiar, comforting, and consistently satisfying.

That dedication has helped the company grow from a small Cape Cod pie shop into a recognizable regional and national brand while maintaining the handcrafted quality that customers expect.

As consumer preferences evolve, the company continues to find ways to introduce new products without losing sight of the values that made it successful in the first place.

The latest product launches reflect that balance between innovation and tradition.

Recognized As The Best Chicken Pie In Massachusetts

Centerville Pie Co.'s commitment to handcrafted quality continues to earn recognition beyond Cape Cod.

The company was recently named the "Best Chicken Pie in Massachusetts of 2026" by BestofBestReview.com, a prestigious authority that recognizes outstanding businesses and products.

The award honors the company's signature chicken pie, the same recipe that gained national attention after being selected as one of Oprah Winfrey's "Favorite Things." As Centerville Pie Co. expands its lineup with new ice cream pies and small savory options, the recognition highlights the enduring popularity of the pie that helped build the brand's reputation.

A Sweet New Take On Classic Desserts

Dessert lovers have a new reason to celebrate.

Centerville Pie Co.'s new Ice Cream Pie Collection combines rich frozen flavors with the company's signature crusts, creating a dessert experience that feels both nostalgic and innovative.

Among the standout flavors are Strawberry Cheesecake, Salted Caramel, and Death by Chocolate, each crafted to deliver a satisfying slice-and-serve experience for family gatherings, holidays, celebrations, and everyday indulgence.

The collection offers consumers a convenient dessert option that requires little preparation while still delivering the premium taste and presentation associated with handcrafted bakery products.

The Strawberry Cheesecake variety blends creamy cheesecake-inspired flavors with the refreshing sweetness of strawberries. Salted Caramel balances rich caramel notes with just the right touch of savory contrast. Death by Chocolate caters to chocolate lovers seeking an indulgent dessert experience layered with bold flavor.

Together, the lineup provides something for nearly every dessert preference while maintaining the quality standards that have become synonymous with the Centerville Pie Co. name.

The launch also reflects growing consumer demand for premium frozen desserts that offer restaurant-quality experiences at home.

Rather than requiring extensive preparation, the pies offer customers an easy way to bring a memorable dessert to the table while enjoying the same attention to detail that has defined the Centerville Pie Co. brand for years.

And for those visiting Cape Cod this summer, the new Ice Cream Pies are available to enjoy at Centerville Pie Co.'s Centerville and Sandwich locations.

Expanding A Best Selling Category

While the new ice cream pies bring excitement to dessert menus, Centerville Pie Co. is also strengthening one of its most popular categories.

The company is introducing three small savory options: the Small Chicken Pot Pie, Small Shepherd’s Pie, and Small Chicken Pie without vegetables. Made with 100 percent white meat chicken, the Small Chicken Pie without vegetables joins a convenient lineup that delivers the handcrafted flavor and quality customers expect for weeknight meals.

Savory pies have long been among the company’s most sought-after offerings, making the new smaller formats a natural extension of the product family. Designed for smaller households, busy schedules, and changing dining habits, the lineup combines portion-conscious convenience with the homemade quality that defines the brand.

Meeting Customer Demand With Trusted Favorites

According to Founder and President Kristin Broadley, the product expansion reflects the company's ongoing commitment to delivering comfort food customers can rely on.

“Our customers want comfort they can trust, and these new pies deliver exactly that,” Broadley said. “From frozen ice cream pies for celebrations to our new small savory pies for weeknight dinners, we're proud to offer products that feel homemade and taste exceptional.” 

That philosophy has helped Centerville Pie Co. build a strong reputation throughout the region and across the country.

By listening closely to customer preferences and adapting to changing market demands, the company continues to strengthen its connection with consumers while expanding its reach into new retail channels.

The result is a product lineup that remains familiar while continuing to evolve.

Growing Through Retail Expansion

The introduction of these new products also supports Centerville Pie Co.'s broader growth strategy.

As demand for premium prepared foods continues to increase, the company is expanding availability through select grocery partners while maintaining its direct connection with customers through its own retail operations and online ordering platform.

This approach allows the brand to reach new consumers who may be discovering Centerville Pie Co. for the first time while continuing to serve longtime customers who have supported the company for years.

Expanded grocery distribution creates greater accessibility without sacrificing the quality and consistency that have helped build the company's reputation.

As additional retail partnerships are introduced throughout the year, more consumers will have the opportunity to experience both the company's established favorites and its newest offerings.

Continuing A Tradition Of Homemade Quality

As consumer preferences evolve, food companies face the challenge of introducing new products without losing the authenticity that customers value.

Centerville Pie Co. appears to be meeting that challenge by focusing on what has always defined its brand: quality ingredients, handcrafted preparation, and flavors designed to bring people together.

Whether customers are serving an Ice Cream Pie at a celebration or preparing one of the new small savory pies during a busy weeknight, the goal remains the same. 

Deliver comfort, convenience, and memorable flavor in every bite.

That commitment to quality has helped make Centerville Pie Co. one of Cape Cod's most recognizable food brands, and these latest additions suggest the company is continuing to build on that foundation.

As the company likes to say, "Give us a taste, we promise you'll feel right at home."

Explore The Latest From Centerville Pie Co.

The new Ice Cream Pie Collection and small savory pie lineup can be purchased online at www.centervillepies.com, at Centerville Pie Co. locations, and at participating local supermarkets. 

Customers visiting Cape Cod this summer are invited to stop by the Centerville or Sandwich locations to try the new Ice Cream Pies and explore the company's full selection of sweet and savory favorites.

With expanded distribution planned throughout the year, customers can expect even greater access to the company's growing lineup of handcrafted pies.

For more information about Centerville Pie Co., its signature pies, and new product offerings, visit the company online at Centerville Pie Company or stop by one of its locations to experience the latest additions firsthand.

Stay connected with Centerville Pie Co. on social media for new product announcements, seasonal pie offerings, special promotions, and behind-the-scenes updates. Follow the company on Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube to keep up with one of Cape Cod's most beloved pie makers.