Amber Pilkington, M.Psy.: Transforming Mental Health with Neuroscience-Informed Therapy for Scrupulosity
Amber Pilkington integrates neuroscience and therapeutic expertise to offer a transformative approach to treating scrupulosity, anxiety, and trauma.
By
Jan 28, 2026
When Anxiety Targets What Matters Most: A Neuroscience-Informed Perspective on Scrupulosity
At first glance, many of Amber Pilkington’s clients appear highly capable and high-functioning. They may be successful in their professional or personal lives and present a picture of outward stability. Beneath the surface, however, many quietly struggle with debilitating anxiety, intrusive thoughts, and entrenched patterns of fear and shame.
For individuals experiencing scrupulosity, a subtype of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) involving intrusive moral or religious fears, this distress is often compounded by isolation and misunderstanding. Scrupulosity is rarely named but widely experienced, and symptoms are frequently misinterpreted as a moral failing or spiritual deficiency rather than an anxiety-based condition. Within faith communities, this misunderstanding can intensify shame and discourage individuals from seeking appropriate care.
Amber Pilkington, Licensed Professional Counselor-Supervisor (LPC-S), brings over 15 years of clinical experience to working with individuals facing these complex concerns. Her practice focuses on scrupulosity and intrusive thoughts through a neuroscience-informed, evidence-based approach that emphasizes understanding the mechanisms underlying anxiety and supporting meaningful therapeutic change over time.
The Journey to a Neuroscience-Informed Approach to Therapy
Early in her career, Amber recognized the limitations of therapy approaches that relied primarily on surface-level coping strategies. While these methods were often helpful in the short term, they did not consistently lead to sustained improvement for clients whose anxiety was deeply ingrained. Many of the individuals she worked with were outwardly high-functioning yet internally overwhelmed—experiencing symptoms that extended beyond what coping skills alone could address.
Seeking a more comprehensive model, Amber pursued advanced training in neuropsychotherapy, an approach grounded in contemporary brain-change science. Neuropsychotherapy emphasizes that therapeutic change involves shifts in neural pathways and requires the integration of both cognitive (top-down) and somatic or nervous-system-based (bottom-up) processes.
This framework became the foundation of her clinical work. Through advanced training, including a Certificate in Neuropsychotherapy, Amber integrates evidence-based modalities such as Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT), and attachment-based approaches. Her work reflects a holistic understanding of the human person, acknowledging the role of the nervous system in shaping emotional experience, thought patterns, and behavior.
Scrupulosity: A Misunderstood Anxiety Disorder
Scrupulosity highlights many of the limitations of traditional mental health frameworks when applied without sufficient clinical nuance. Often described as a subtype of OCD, scrupulosity involves persistent intrusive thoughts related to morality or religion, accompanied by compulsive behaviors aimed at reducing anxiety or achieving certainty.
Individuals with scrupulosity frequently experience heightened guilt, fear, and reassurance-seeking, which can develop into a reinforcing cycle of anxiety and emotional exhaustion. Over time, these patterns may leave individuals feeling disconnected from their values and beliefs.
Amber conceptualizes scrupulosity as an anxiety disorder rooted in the brain’s threat-detection system rather than a failure of willpower or faith.
“Scrupulosity isn’t a sign of weak faith or poor character,” Amber explains. “It’s an anxiety disorder that attaches itself to what matters most to a person.”
This reframing often helps reduce shame and allows clients to engage in treatment grounded in neuroscience rather than self-blame.
A Compassionate and Science-Based Approach
Amber’s work emphasizes the integration of scientific understanding with clinical compassion. Rather than focusing solely on diagnosis or symptom management, therapy supports clients in understanding how their nervous system contributes to anxiety patterns—and how those patterns can gradually be reshaped.
“Meaningful change in therapy involves brain change,” Amber notes. “Whether through learning, emotional processing, or relational experience, therapy works by helping the nervous system learn something new.”
By addressing both cognitive insight and embodied experience, therapy supports nervous system regulation and psychological flexibility. Clients are guided toward responding to intrusive thoughts with greater awareness and tolerance for uncertainty rather than fear-driven reactions.
Professional Recognition
In 2026, Amber Pilkington was recognized by the Evergreen Awards as Best Anxiety & OCD Therapist – Scrupulosity Specialist (U.S.). This recognition reflects her specialized clinical focus, commitment to evidence-based care, and contributions to increasing awareness of scrupulosity as a frequently misunderstood anxiety condition.
Educational Mission: The Catholic Counseling Institute
In addition to her clinical practice, Amber is the founder of the Catholic Counseling Institute, a separate educational platform offering psychoeducational resources for Catholics seeking a faith-integrated understanding of mental health.
Educational programs such as Freedom From Scrupulosity & Intrusive Thoughts: A Catholic Educational Approachexplore the intersection of psychological science and Catholic moral theology while remaining firmly educational in scope. These resources are designed to complement—not replace—professional mental health treatment.
While Amber’s counseling practice remains clinically grounded and secular, her educational work provides a thoughtful space where psychology and theology can intersect ethically and responsibly.
A Commitment to Healing and Client Dignity
At the core of Amber Pilkington’s work is a deep respect for the dignity of the human person.
“Effective therapy isn’t about erasing thoughts or fixing people,” she says. “It’s about helping the brain and body experience safety again so values, relationships, and meaning can come back online.”
For individuals burdened by anxiety, guilt, and shame, her neuroscience-informed approach offers clarity and a grounded path forward—one rooted in understanding how the brain and nervous system adapt over time.
Related Links:
